Ghislaine Maxwell should not be allowed to rummage through the teenage diary of the girl recognized as”Minor Victim-2″ in her indictment, federal prosecutors told a judge on Tuesday.
Back in March, the receiver of the subpoena was identified with her lawyers as Annie Farmer, among the 2 siblings described by the New York Times as”The Sisters Who Tried to Eliminate Jeffrey Epstein.”
Farmer had been 16 years old if she stated she had been subjected to some topless massage in Epstein’s ranch in New Mexico in 1996.
Her sister Maria Farmer also alleged that Epstein and Maxwell assaulted her at billionaire Les Wexner’s Ohio home, in which she possessed a guest home, in an incident the elder Farmer maintains she reported to the New York City Police Department and the FBI.
“To the extreme detriment of Maria and Annie–and also countless other victims who came after them–authorities disregarded Maria’s reporting efforts and took no action,” lawyers for its younger Farmer sister composed in a litigation in 2019.
Lawyers David Boies (L) and Brad Edwards (R) speak to the media together with alleged sufferer Annie Farmer following a bail hearing in US financier Jeffrey Epstein’s sex trafficking case on July 15, 2019 in nyc.
It is undisputed that Farmer didn’t write about Maxwell in her diary, but the accused gender trafficker’s lawyers want the journal anyhow, which the shield views as exculpatory.
Prosecutors say that there is a motive Maxwell does not seem in its pages.
“Since the government explained in its own resistance to this motion, the government understands that Minor Victim-2 ceased writing in her diary shortly after assembly Jeffrey Epstein, so there are not any entries about her later trip with Epstein, during which she met the defendant,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Maurene Comey composed in a 9-page letter into U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan.
“The victim provided the authorities with her admissions regarding Epstein, which the authorities in turn produced to the shield,” the letter continued. “The remainder of the diary consists of Minor Victim-2’s unrelated private diary entries, along with the defendant has not clarified and cannot explain why she needs to review those entrances to set up a fact that the government has confessed.”
Maxwell’s lawyers say that they learned diary’s presence become public when Farmer used partial pages of it civil lawsuit against people and they would like to deliver it for forensic analysis.
“Inspection of the entire diary is necessary to ascertain whether the diary is authentic and complete and whether spoliation has happened,” Maxwell’s attorney Jeffrey S. Pagliuca composed in late April. “This evaluation requires the assistance of an experienced forensic document examiner and cannot be performed in the middle of trial with no significant disruption in the proceedings.”
Replying that this debate”lacks merit,” prosecutors notice that Maxwell’s defense group”does not recognize any basis for doubting the credibility of the papers,” they expect Farmer to authenticate at trial.
“The suspect’s bare assertion that authenticity might somehow be doubt is hardly a sufficiently detailed explanation of value and admissibility to justify a subpoena for a minor victim’s personal diary,” the administration’s letter states.
Farmer’s attorney Sigrid S. McCawley and prosecutors both telephone Maxwell’s petition a”fishing trip”
Prosecutors also want Judge Nathan to reject Maxwell’s subpoena for boots which Farmer says Epstein gave her at the ranch.
“Upon arriving, Maxwell and Epstein took Annie buying and lavished her with gifts, including beauty products along with a pair of brand-new cowboy boots,” Farmer’s lawsuit against Epstein’s property and Maxwell stated.
On April 23, Maxwell’s defense counsel wanted to inspect the boots.
“The evaluation will determine the manufacture and provenance of their boots, something that would be difficult to perform during some trial with no significant delay,” the defense’s letter stated.
Prosecutors stated that they asked Farmer’s lawyers to flip the boots over the FBI and that she will”probably agree to achieve that.”
Initially scheduled for July, Maxwell’s trial has been postponed until autumn in light of new sex-trafficking charges that a grand jury indicted her for in March. She has been accused of grooming and abusing girls for women’s predation. Her brand latest trial date has not yet been set, and she will be tried individually on perjury claims linked to her civil lawsuit with Virginia Giuffre, who uttered Maxwell for denying that she turned her to Epstein’s”sex slave.”
Browse the government’s resistance to Maxwell’s subpoenas below:
(image via JOHANNES EISELE/AFP via Getty Images)
Have a tip we have to know?